SCHOOL BUS INFORMATION CENTER


 

School Bus Facts

 Information for Reporters Covering School Bus Stories

(888) 367-7242

 

 

Yellow school buses are a great American success story, with a safety record that is unequalled in the transportation industry.  Yet crashes involving school buses always make news.

This fact sheet is intended to help you if there is a crash or other school bus issue in your community.  All information can be used without restriction and attributed to The School Bus Information Center, unless otherwise noted.

 

When reporting about school bus incidents, please consider the circumstances carefully. For example, was the bus at fault, or was the other vehicle?  Was a child struck getting on or of fthe bus because a motorist failed to obey the law and stop for the bus?  Were serious injuries avoided because the bus structure provided excellent overall crash protection even under severe circumstances?

 

Additionally, local school boards often debate issues such as funding for pupil transportation,whether school buses should have safety belts, and bus driver training requirements.  This fact sheet also provides useful background information for those stories. 

Statistics

 

Outstanding safety record.  There is no safer way to transport a child than in a school bus.  Fatal crashes involving school bus occupants are rare events, even though school buses serve daily in every community. Every school day, some 475,000 yellow school buses transport more than 25 million children to and from schools and school-related activities.

 

Driving your children to school is not safer.  The Transportation Research Board of the National Academy of Sciences estimates that every year more than 800 school-aged children are killed as occupants in other motor vehicles or as pedestrians or bicyclists during “normal school transport hours.”  Most of these deaths could be prevented if children rode in school buses. Parents need to know that driving a child to school—or allowing them to ride to school with other teenagers--is not a safety smart decision—hands down, the school bus is the safest way to and from school. 

 

Commitment to excellence.  Your child’s school bus meets or exceeds federal and state laws involving safety,security, vehicle emissions and driver skills and other qualifications.

 

Largest mass transit program in the U.S.  School buses provide approximately 10 billion student trips per year ---8.8 billion "to-and-from school" trips and an estimated 1.2 billion activity trips.  In contrast, transit buses provide only about 5.2 billion unlinked passenger trips each year in the U.S.(i.e. getting to a destination by using a single bus instead of multiple connections).  Yet, pupil transportation receives no federal funding.

 

Occupant Fatalities.  Based on the latest federal statistics, last year, 5 children were killed as passengers in school buses   Forty-seven states did not have a single child killed as a school bus passenger.    When a fatality occurs it typically involves severe circumstances. 

 

Pedestrian fatalities.  Last year, 29 children were killed as pedestrians getting on or off a school bus, or while waiting at the school bus stop—usually the result of motorists passing a stopped school bus illegally.

 

School Bus-Related Child Fatalities by State*

(School bus traveling to / from school or school activities)

 

State

 passengers

 pedestrians

 

State

passengers

pedestrians

Alabama

None

None

 

Montana

None

None

Alaska

None

None

 

Nebraska

None

None

Arizona

None

None

 

Nevada

None

1

Arkansas

None

None

 

New Hampshire

None

None

California

None

2

 

New Jersey

None

None

Colorado

None

None

 

New Mexico

None

None

Connecticut

None

 None

 

New York

None

 2

Delaware

None

None

 

North Carolina

None

None

Washington, DC

None

None

 

North Dakota

None

None

Florida

None

 2

 

Ohio

None

 1

Georgia

 None

 None

 

Oklahoma

1

None

Hawaii

None

None

 

Oregon

None

None

Idaho

None

None

 

Pennsylvania

None

3

Illinois

None

 4

 

Rhode Island

None

None

Indiana

None

1

 

South Carolina

None

1

Iowa

None

None

 

South Dakota

None

None

Kansas

 None

None

 

Tennessee

None

None

Kentucky

None

None

 

Texas

None

3

Louisiana

None

None

 

Utah

None

None

Maine

None

None

 

Vermont

None

None

Maryland

None

None

 

Virginia

3

3

Massachusetts

None

None

 

Washington

None

 2

Michigan

None

1

 

West Virginia

None

None

Minnesota

None

2

 

Wisconsin

None

 1

Mississippi

None

None

 

Wyoming

None

None

Missouri

1

None

 

 

*Source:  National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS).  2005 is the latest available data.

Safety Equipment Required on School Buses

 

School buses are equipped with more safety equipment than any other vehicle on the road.  This is by design because federal safety regulators and state pupil transportation officials always err on the side of providing an extra margin of safety.  The size of the school bus alone gives it an important advantage in all but the most catastrophic circumstances. Key federal safety requirements includes:  

 

  • Well-padded, high-back, energy-absorbing seats, as well as special requirements for wheelchair restraint systems.  Additionally, school bus interiors are designed to reduce the chances of injury caused by sharp edges or body panels that may tear loose in a crash 
  • Brake systems that enable the school bus to stop in a shorter distance than other large vehicles
  • Lights and reflective devices that indicate when the bus is loading and unloading passengers 
  • Additional mirrors that allow the driver to see all critical areas directly in front of and along both sides of the school bus 
  • A stop arm that extends out to the left side of the bus to warn motorists when the bus is loading or unloading passengers /
  • Several emergency exits  
  • Rollover protection that reduces the likelihood of a roof collapse and allows for operable emergency exits even after the roof is subject to extreme forces
  • Protected fuel tanks, and fuel pump, fuel delivery system, emissions control lines and connections to protect against fuel spills in severe crashes.

 

Why No Seat Belts on School Buses?

 

Especially after a local crash, parents often ask, “My car has seat belts.  Why not my child’s school bus?”  

A school bus is very different than the family car, so a different occupant protection strategy has been used since April 1, 1977. 

 

Because of its superior size and extensive structural and other safety equipment a school bus tends to come out best in most crashes. Instead of seat belts, school buses use a passive approach called “compartmentalization, ”well padded, high back, energy absorbing seats.  Simply stated, the goal of this approach is to package children like eggs.  It has performed extremely well in providing a high level of safety to the many sizes of children who ride school buses, ranging from pre-schoolers up to high school football players riding to games in full gear.

 

In 2002, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the federal agency responsible for school bus safety requirements, completed an extensive evaluation of school bus passenger protection and reported to the Congress these findings:

 

  • Lap belts installed on large school buses would have little, if any benefit in reducing serious-fatal injuries.

 

  • Lap/shoulder belts, if used properly, could save one life a year.  However, NHTSA noted this estimated benefit assumed 100 percent usage and no misuse [in our view an impossible standard to meet in a mass transit environment].  NHTSA also reported that serious neck and perhaps abdominal injuries could result from misuse.

 

NHTSA also said that if states and local school districts decide to require lap/shoulder belts they should be aware of“unintended consequences,” including reduced bus capacity (only two children to a seat instead of three to accommodate lap/shoulder belts), meaning that fewer children could be served unless additional buses were purchased to offset the capacity loss.  Reduced capacity could result in more children being injured or killed because they would be forced to walk, ride bicycles, or ride to school with parents or other students.  The agency advised Congress, states and local school districts not to force these less safe alternatives.

 

NAPT does not oppose lap/shoulder belts in school buses if beyond a reasonable doubt they would improve the safety of children riding in school buses.  But it is NHTSA’s job to make this regulatory determination.  Some states on their own have begun installing seat belts.

 

In February 2007 NAPT formally petitioned NHTSA to reevaluate on a priority basis its school bus seating standard “with the goal of establishing a safety system that will definitively enhance the current passenger crash protection for all children that ride a school bus.”

In the summer of 2007 NHTSA held a public meeting to discuss whether the addition of lap/shoulder seat belts, or other protective measures, would further improve the safety of children riding in large school buses.

 

NHTSA announced that later in 2007 it would issue a Notice of Proposed Rule-making to seek formal comments on whatever measures it concludes would be the most promising.  At a later date, a final rule would be issued bringing an end to the uncertainty.  The agency could propose the addition of lap/shoulder seat belts, improvements to the existing “compartmentalization” requirement, a combination of these two, or that the existing “compartmentalization”requirement is performing well within the framework of the cost vs. benefit calculation that NHTSA must conduct before issuing a federal requirement.

 

Other Key Facts

 

Commitment to clean air. Many generations of Americans have been transported safely in diesel-powered school buses with no known ill health effects.  Even before government requirements the school bus industry encouraged and used the best possible emissions practices. As older buses are retired, most are replaced with latest “green” diesel engines or natural gas, and all buses in the U.S. now use the much cleaner ultra low sulfur diesel fuel.  Model year 2007 school buses are 60 times cleaner than those built in 1990, and since 2003 some 12,000 school buses have been retrofitted with emissions recovery technology.

 

Your child’s school bus is driven by a professional.  While the structure of school bus provides protection in crashes, it’s the skill and performance of highly trained school bus drivers that often prevents crashes and other incidents.  Drivers all have a Commercial Drivers License (CDL) with school bus endorsement; and receive training in security, emergency medical and student behavior management.  They are also subject to random drug/alcohol testing and other requirements.

 

Security.  In the post 9/11 world, the security of children riding in school buses, and at the facilities where buses are stored is a major concern.  Even without federal guidelines or any funding, the school bus industry conducted its own assessment and training of operators and drivers.

 

Last update: 7/10/2009
NAPT •
1840 Western Avenue • Albany, NY 12203
(800) 989-NAPT or (518) 452-3611 • Fax (518) 218-0867 •
info@napt.org

© 2009 National Association for Pupil Transportation.

All rights reserved.